Skip to content
Daily Theology
  • Podcast
  • Shark WeekS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Search
Bishops, Catholic Identity, Catholic Social Teaching, Catholicism, Current Events, Liturgy, Ministry, Politics, Pope, Pope Francis, Theology and Church, Theology and Culture, Theology and Society, Women Religious
by Kevin AhernSeptember 24, 201511:51 pmSeptember 30, 2015

A Tale of Two Churches: The 1% Shall Be First and the Religious Shall be Last

pope StpatsUpon arriving in New York, Pope Francis immediately traveled to the center of the city’s ecclesial and civic life for a service of “Vespers with the Clergy, Men and Women Religious” at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in midtown Manhattan. What a great idea!

And what a great joy that the pope would take the time to address women religious, many of whom have felt so marginalized by the church under two recent investigations. By far, the height of his homily during the vespers is when he spoke directly to women religious:

“In a special way I would like to express my esteem and gratitude to the religious women of the United States. What would the Church be without you? Women of strength, fighters, with that spirit of courage which puts you in the front lines in the proclamation of the Gospel. To you, religious women, sisters and mothers of this people, I wish to say “thank you”, a big thank you… and to tell you that I love you very much”

He also had some brotherly advice to his fellow priests, urging them to become closer to the poor and find time for what James Keenan, SJ has described as self-care. “Rest is needed,” the pope stressed, “as are moments of leisure and self-enrichment.” What a great message for our priests who are often overworked and unappreciated.

See the text here.

It makes sense that the pope would want to have a special moment with his fellow priests and a special moment with other vowed religious who have given their entire lives to live the Gospel in poverty, chastity, poverty, and obedience (remember the pope is both a priest and a religious).

In a perfect world, I would hope that a special prayer service would have also been organized for lay people who also give their time, talent and treasure as catechists, volunteers, social workers, parish council members, liturgical ministers and theologians. I might also expect that in a prayer service for religious, that leaders of religious communities might formally welcome the pope to NY along with the cardinal. But it’s not a perfect world and insofar as it is a human institution, it’s not a perfect church.

But even in an imperfect church the average person might assume that a “Vespers with the Clergy, Men and Women Religious” (the official title of the event) might feature, include and promote women and men religious and secular clergy. Sadly, that was only half the story at St. Patrick’s tonight.

Instead of being filled with religious and priests who have given their lives to the building up the people of God, many of the participants, particularly in the front rows were VIPs and wealthy donors to Cardinal Dolan’s 175 Million Dollar renovation of St. Patrick’s. The VIPs included Ken Langone, a “mega-donor” who has a terrible track record on worker rights and who has compared efforts for addressing income inequality to the Nazis. Yes, this is the same Langone who threatened to withdraw money from the cathedral restoration project after the pope’s criticism of capitalism.

Not only did Langone get a prime seat for his money, but he also was one of the first, after Senator Schumer, Governor Cuomo and Mayor de Blasio to greet the pope when he arrived. Why didn’t a religious woman, religious brother, and secular priest welcome the pope when he arrived for the vespers? Why not young people formation to become nuns and priests?

But it was not just about seating. Beyond the pope, the skilled cantor, and Cardinal Dolan, the only people to participate in the liturgy were not religious. The reading and the petitions were read by the wealthy.

Apparently, however, the VIP donors were upset that their seats were not good enough for the money. Earlier this week on Fox News, Fox Business correspondent Charles Gasparino pleaded the case for the donors who were only given “good seats.” (Today, Gasparino went on to muse about Jesus being a capitalist.). Likely echoing the sentiments of many, Gasparino seems confused at why nuns might get better seats than the big donors as he says :

“As you know, a lot of Wall Street guys gave a lot of money to this. They raised a lot of money over the last couple of years to renovate this thing. They thought they would have better seating.”

Well they did have better seating and they were invited to an event for religious that most religious in the NYC area did not get the chance to attend. The presence of Henry Kissinger, who many perceive as a war criminal and supporter of regimes that actively persecuted religious women and men committed to justice was particularly disturbing. Money and power, in New York, buys privilege and I guess it’s the same in our Cathedral. What would Dorothy Day, someone quoted by the pope earlier in the day in his congressional address, say to that?

Pope Francis Greeting Sr. Noel (www.maryknoll.org)
Pope Francis Greeting Sr. Noel (www.maryknoll.org)

What upsets me so much about this tale of two churches is that there are literally thousands of women and men religious who have given all of their lives (not just a tiny portion of their net worth) to building up the church within a short bus ride of New York City. Some retired women religious face near poverty living conditions as their communities struggle to fund the costs of medical care. In other, words, there were plenty of people who could have filled St. Patrick’s.

Thankfully, there was one special woman religious who got to meet the pope at the Vespers.

After a social media campaign, Sr. Noel Divine, an 88-year old Maryknoll Sister, who is unable to speak because of a degenerative condition, was given a ticket and the Pope warmly greeted her on his way out. Like Pope Francis and Dorothy Day,  Noel reminds us that the Gospel is lived in service with our eyes fixed on God’s Reign. We should be thankful to those who give money to our buildings, but let’s not forget about those who give their lives to the true church, the people of God!

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tagged with: #pope #popeinNYC #popeinUS Cardinal Dolan Men and Women Religious Pope at St. Patrick's Pope Francis religious Vespers with the Clergy

Kevin Ahern

All posts

Kevin Glauber Ahern, PhD is an assistant professor of religious studies at Manhattan College. He defended his doctoral dissertation in Theological Ethics from Boston College in 2013. His dissertation was entitled “Structures of Grace: Catholic NGOs and the Church’s Mission in a Globalized World.” From 2003 to 2007, Kevin Ahern served as the President of the International Movement of Catholic Students (IMCS-Pax Romana), an international network of students in over eighty countries. He continues to be active on the boards of several national and international networks, including the Catholic Common Ground Initiative, the board of directors of America Press and as a Vice-President of the ICMICA-Pax Romana, He has edited the Radical Bible and Visions of Hope: Emerging Theologians and the Future of the Church, both with Orbis Books. When not teaching, writing, or going to international meetings, Kevin enjoys hiking, Cape Cod, and spending time with his wife. Follow him on twitter at @kevin_ahern

  • Profile at Academia
  • Kevin J Ahern's page.

5Comments

Add yours
  1. 1
    ammoncircuit on September 25, 2015 at 7:39 am
    Reply

    Did you see the look of disgust on the Pope’s face during Cardinal Dolan’s address?

  2. 2
    Everyday Voices on September 25, 2015 at 4:14 pm
    Reply

    Reblogged this on Everyday Voices and commented:
    The Catholic Church and its multitude of charities do not exist as a vanity project for the rich when they’ve retired and need a big tax write off from Uncle Sam. Though large donations are very necessary to the survival of the individual institutions within the church, large donors should treat their donation just as that, a gift without expecting anything in return, just like when they buy themselves a fancy car or penthouse. A gift to the church you feel that was instrumental in your success in business and (hopefully) as a human being. If wealthy donors of the church donate to get their name on a wall or special treatment from the Pope, then they are totally misguided in the meaning of ‘charity’ as prescribed by the church. To give is a greater gift than to receive. You do not and should not expect anything in return when you give. Otherwise it’s not a gift.

    To threaten to rescind a pledge or donation just because the Pope criticized corporate greed, which, by the way, is totally legitimate and to twist the Pope’s message of allowing all willing and able persons a chance a prosperity into creating envy and jealousy into the rich and the not, is self-serving and very un-Christian.

    If this is how Ken Langone feels about the Pope’s message, then he best keep his money and donated it to the Republican Party instead which they will put to great use as bashing poor for their own plight.

    The tenants of charity, kindness, mercy and social justice are about the only things that is holding the Catholic church together. The church has been rocked by scandal, charges of hypocrisy, bigotry and discrimination against divorced persons, intermarried Catholics, gay marriage and same-sex families, so, pretty much the only thing it has going for it is its fundamental teachings of charity, humility, caring about the least in society, the downtrodden – in a word social justice. The amazing work that is done by anonymous members of the church who care about people that are worse off is what is keeping the church going. Not the likes of Ken Langone and his ilk.

  3. 3
    What Sort of Person Do I Want To Be?: A Virtue Ethics Analysis of Pope Francis in the United States – Annie Selak | Political Theology Today on September 25, 2015 at 5:08 pm
    Reply

    […] with the vast majority of tickets going to those who are privileged or connected. (Kevin Ahern’s A Tale of Two Churches: The 1% Shall Be First and the Religious Shall Be Last is an important read on the topic of privilege and accessibility during the papal visit). Yet this […]

  4. 4
    Twenty-First Sunday after Pentecost | Javen Swanson on October 18, 2015 at 2:11 pm
    Reply

    […] Kevin Ahern, “A Tale of Two Churches: The 1% Shall Be First and the Religious Shall Be Last,” on (DT) Daily Theology, https://dailytheology.org/2015/09/24/a-tale-of-two-churches-the-1-shall-be-first-and-the-religious-sh…. […]

  5. 5
    Annina Lion on January 25, 2016 at 10:33 am
    Reply

    You said/wrote it as it was and is. I thank you for your courage to speak out the truth of the matter and how money can tie our hands. Sister AML

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Cancel

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook!

Recent Posts

  • On The Privileges of Personhood
  • Invitation to an Antifascist Reading Space
  • Beyond Kendi: Antiracism and Non-White Sovereignty in the US Political Economy
  • Sinful and Holy: The Human Nature of the Church
Advertisements

Archive

Advertisements

Follow DT on Twitter

My Tweets
Advertisements

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook!
Advertisements

Tags

Advent Anti-Racism Catholic Catholic Church Catholicism Catholic Social Teaching Christianity Christmas Church College Theology Society discipleship faith Holy Spirit Hope Jesuits Jesus Jesus Christ Lent liberation theology love Mercy Oscar Romero podcast podcast season 1 Pope Francis Prayer racism Saint Leo University Saints spirituality Stephen Okey Stephen Okey Podcast Episode Theological Shark Week theology theology and culture
Advertisements

Authors

  • Amanda Osheim
  • Alexandria Griffin
  • Benjamin Durheim
  • Brian Flanagan
  • B. Kevin Brown
  • Brianne Jacobs
  • erik martin
  • Catherine R. Osborne
  • Christine E. McCarthy
  • Leo Guardado
  • Kelly L. Schmidt & Billy Critchley-Menor, S.J.
  • The Editors
  • Guest Post
  • DT Podcast
  • Dave de la Fuente
  • Dannis Matteson
  • Heather M. DuBois
  • Gunnar B. Gundersen
  • John DeCostanza
  • Jessica Wrobleski
  • Kevin M Johnson
  • John P. Slattery
  • Katharine Mahon
  • Katherine Wrisley Shelby
  • Kathleen Bellow
  • Br. Ken Homan, SJ
  • Kevin Ahern
  • Katherine A. Greiner
  • Krista Stevens
  • Andrew Staron
  • Lorraine Cuddeback-Gedeon
  • Marjorie Corbman
  • Michael L. Avery
  • Marcus Mescher
  • Michael Rubbelke
  • Meg Stapleton Smith
  • Katie O'Neill
  • Paul Louis Metzger
  • Stephen Okey
Advertisements
Advertisements

Categories

Advent Catholicism Catholic Social Teaching Christian Life Church Community Conversation Conversion Current Events Discipleship Doing Theology Ethics Faith Guest Post Jesus Christ Justice Lent Mercy Podcast Politics Pop Culture Pope Francis Racism Saints Shark Week Social Justice Solidarity Spirituality Theology and Culture Vatican
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements

Tags

#Laudato Si Advent Anti-Racism Catholic Catholic Church Catholic Higher Education Catholicism Catholic Social Teaching Christianity Christmas Church College Theology Society Community conversation dialogue discipleship education Ethics Eucharist faith Forgiveness grace Higher Education Holy Spirit Hope Incarnation Jesuits Jesus Jesus Christ John DeCostanza John Paul II Kevin Ahern Lent liberation theology Liturgy love Martin Luther King Mary Media Mercy Ministry Oscar Romero peace Pentecost podcast podcast season 1 podcast season 2 Pope Benedict XVI Pope Francis Prayer Public Theology Race racism resurrection Saint Leo University Saints scripture Shark Week social justice spirituality Stephen Okey Stephen Okey Podcast Episode Teaching Teaching Theology technology Theological Shark Week theology theology and culture Thomas Merton Vacation Bible School Vatican Vatican II vocation war white supremacy
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements
Website Built with WordPress.com.
Footer navigation
  • About Us
  • Theological Shark Weeks
  • DT Podcast
  • Who We Are

Begin typing your search above and press return to search. Press Esc to cancel.

  • Follow Following
    • Daily Theology
    • Join 8,346 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Daily Theology
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.

    %d bloggers like this: