A Nun, “No One,” and the Voice

It was a go-CRISTINA-SCUCCIA-NUN-THE-VOICE-ITALY-facebookift first thing in the morning. I noticed on my Facebook newsfeed a story about an Sr. Cristina Scuccia, an Italian member of the Ursuline Sisters of the Holy Family, and her stunning performance of “No One” (originally by Alicia Keys) on the Italian version of the popular tv show, The Voice.

Her voice, enthusiasm, and spirit brought the crowd to its feet and tears to the eyes of at least one judge. Watch here.

Soon after watching, I came across an article in “The Atlantic” questioning the enthusiastic response of the crowd and wondering to what degree they were excited by the novelty of the scene, rather than by a response to the performance or to a genuine value of seeing a vowed religious in this context. It’s author, Emma Green, writes:

“It’s just that in this case, it’s unclear whether the entertainment value is earnest or sarcastic: Is this clip delightful because Sister Scuccia’s voice is powerful and her enthusiasm palpable? Or is it enjoyable because it’s a spectacle to see a bride of Christ dancing on television?”

These are strong questions arising from a legitimate concern that our society of spectacle embraces even (or perhaps especially?) religiosity in a way that does not, at the same time, invite reflection and allow for the possibility of deep transformation toward God.

But while granting the validity of that concern, I think that it echoes, at least a bit, the scandal that is at the heart of our faith: that God became flesh and lived among us. To live with us was most certainly a risk for Christ, and to do so in a way that bore witness to perfect love was to risk our rejection of that love. “God does not belong here,” we can imagine ourselves saying while faced with the incarnation. “God does not belong here in this mundane part of my life… in my decisions about my career, in my choices about how to spend my money and my time. God does not belong here, haunting my relationships with my spouse and my children, lurking in my entertainment. God does not belong here in my flesh, more intimate to me than I am to myself.”

“I came here because I have a gift and I want to share that gift. I am here to evangelize,” Sr. Scuccia said. Evangelizing, of course, can mean talking about the Gospel. But it can also mean embracing it and embracing the risk of spectacle, the risk of rejection, or even the risk of radical transformation. It can mean calling attention to the presence of God in the most unlikely places. Even on a tv show.

Andrew Staron is an assistant professor of theology at Wheeling Jesuit University in Wheeling, West Virginia. 

7 responses to “A Nun, “No One,” and the Voice

  1. Watching the clip earlier today made me all teary-eyed, and your post has had much the same impact.

    What you say about the Incarnation is so true. That is always the problem with God made flesh, we love to “profess” it, but so often we just can’t take the real thing.

    As I watched her, all I could think about what her sense of joy, how her whole body moved and how her voice rang out. I loved seeing her sisters in the back, so thrilled. And then I had the thought… I wonder how many people just do not think that this can be a nun. That nuns just can’t do that. Or worse yet, that they should not.

    I could make out part of what she said, and I know she was out there for Christ. It is a moving clip… in more ways than one! But your post, now that really adds food for thought. Thank you.

  2. Thank you, Fran. I had a similar reaction when I first watched. After reading Emma Green’s article, I began to wonder if she was right. But what really got me thinking was my own reaction to the performance–and I wanted to explore why I (apparently along with others) might consider that there’s something out of place about the whole thing. I think it’s ultimately less about a religious sister, per se, and more about our assumptions about the proper and improper place for God in the world.

    You certainly hit the target when you spoke of joy–and Teresa of Calcutta commented once that joy is the net by which we catch souls. Evangelization indeed.

  3. We compartmentalize our lives and put God in a little box rather than letting God be part of everything that we do and everywhere that we go. What a surprise to find out that God is there whether we expect God or not! God is everywhere and in everything and in everyone. Thank you for this post.

  4. But when Christ came among us He spoke as God, He acted as God, He lived as God and not a pharisee… or pop singer. Yes! He elevated our nature by coming among us and gave us an example as did His Blessed Mother. I don’t see Our Lady belting out pop songs, but converting pop singers to a more reverent and prayerful way of life

  5. Pingback: The Nun and the Rapper and Why it Matters·

  6. Pingback: Irmã Cristina Scuccia e a Alegria do Evangelho - Blog do Jonas·

  7. Pingback: “Like a Virgin” touched (by God?!) for the very first time | Daily Theology·

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s